Published

Fiberglass vs Cellulose Attic Insulation: Cost, R-Value, and Installation

Fiberglass and cellulose are the two least expensive insulation families for most homes, and both can be installed as loose-fill on an attic floor [4]. ENERGY STAR lists cellulose and fiberglass loose-fill/blown-in products as intermediate-skill choices for unfinished attic floors and hard-to-reach places, and it stresses that performance depends heavily on installation quality [1]. The practical comparison is therefore not just material price: it is R-value per inch, installed cost at the same target R-value, and whether the job is done to the manufacturer's depth and coverage instructions [1][2].

For attic loose-fill, R-value per inch is the first dividing line. Fiberglass loose-fill is listed at about R-2.2 to R-2.7 per inch in an attic, while loose-fill cellulose is about R-3.2 per inch; dense-packed cellulose in a closed cavity can reach R-3.8 per inch [2][3]. That means an R-49 target needs roughly 15 inches of cellulose at R-3.2 per inch [5], while fiberglass may require 16 to 26 inches and enough room at the eaves to fit that depth [2]. Blown-in fiberglass can cover a wider R-2 to R-4.2 per inch range depending on density, but the lower attic loose-fill figure is the one to use when comparing attic floor space [2].

Cost figures need to be compared at the same R-value and scope. One buyer's guide lists blown-in fiberglass at about $1.95 to $2.60 per sq ft generally and about $1.95 to $2.25 per sq ft to reach R-38 in an attic; it lists blown-in cellulose at about $1.50 to $2 per sq ft [2]. A separate article gives a much lower cellulose figure—42 cents to 99 cents per sq ft to insulate to R-38—so the two figures should not be treated as a single apples-to-apples price without matching scope and density assumptions [3]. Use published ranges to budget, then get bids that state the target R-value, settled depth, and number of bags [2][3].

Environmental and material differences are clearer. Cellulose is typically 75% to 80% ground-up newspaper by weight, mixed with a borate-based fire retardant, and it has low embodied energy and high recycled content [2][3]. Cellulose is also denser than fiberglass and more resistant to airflow, which helps it reduce air leakage [2][3]. Fiberglass has its own practical profile: blown-in fiberglass uses shorter, smaller fibers that installers often report are less itchy than batts, but installers should still wear a dust mask [3]. ENERGY STAR certified insulation must be third-party tested and meet flame-resistance requirements, and certified manufacturers must provide installation and safety instructions [1].

Air sealing belongs before the insulation decision. Neither cellulose nor fiberglass is an air barrier; both allow air to pass and need to be paired with an air barrier, and fiberglass's effective R-value is particularly sensitive to airflow [4]. In a vented attic, loose-fill at the attic floor can also suffer wind washing near soffit vents, so the attic floor should be air-sealed and vent baffles kept in place before blowing insulation [4][5]. Moisture is another shared limitation: both materials can trap moisture, though their high air permeability also lets them dry quickly when the assembly allows it [4]. A best-practice attic job starts with an airtight ceiling plane and an empty or well-planned attic, not with insulation alone [5].

Installation method changes the risk. ENERGY STAR says insulation performance is highly dependent on installation quality, and manufacturers must include clear installation and safety instructions [1]. Blown-in products need special equipment; big-box-store blowers are often adequate for loose-fill attic floors but usually cannot achieve the high densities needed for dense-packed closed cavities, which calls for more powerful rental or contractor equipment [2]. Fiberglass batts need no special equipment, but sloppy batts can reduce effectiveness [4]; blown-in cellulose in an attic needs a blower and some training [4]. If you hire out, require the contractor to document depth and bag count, because those are the field checks that show whether the specified R-value was actually delivered [3].

Bag count and settling are the two verification traps. For loose-fill fiberglass, use the manufacturer's coverage chart: one worked example for R-49 in a 1,500 sq ft attic calls for at least 25.2 bags per 1,000 sq ft, which adjusts to about 37.8 bags—so fewer than 38 bags would fall short of that table, and the installed thickness should match the minimum depth printed on the same chart [3]. Cellulose settles over time, potentially up to 20%, and manufacturers print initial thickness tables so the settled thickness reaches the target R-value [3]. Blown-in fiberglass does not settle unless it is fluffed [3]. Check the bag table for the exact product rather than assuming one depth works for every brand [3].

Choose cellulose when higher R-value per inch, recycled content, and better airflow resistance matter and you can plan for settling; choose fiberglass when you want a loose-fill product that does not settle and your attic has the depth for its lower R-per-inch [2][3]. In either case, compare bids at the same target R-value, confirm the settled depth and bag count, and air-seal before insulating [1][3][5]. You can use the site's R-Value to U-Factor Calculator to check the R-value implied by a proposed material thickness before you compare quotes, using the manufacturer's R-per-inch data as the input [2]. One attic guide notes that if the attic is used for storage or mechanical equipment, or the ceiling is hard to air-seal, insulating the roof and bringing the attic inside the thermal envelope is the alternative—at higher cost and complexity [5].

Sources and dates checked

  1. Choosing the Appropriate Insulation Type | ENERGY STAR (2026-11-23)
  2. Buyer's Guide to Blown-in Insulation - Fine Homebuilding (2026-11-23)
  3. Blown Insulation for Attics: Fiberglass vs. Cellulose - Fine Homebuilding (2026-11-23)
  4. Fiberglass versus Cellulose - GreenBuildingAdvisor (2026-11-23)
  5. What's the Best Attic Insulation? - Fine Homebuilding (2026-11-23)

This article was created with AI assistance and checked by our automated editorial process.

General information; not a binding quote or individual investment, legal, engineering or medical advice.